Mechanical Vs. Fixed Blade Broadheads

The argument of mechanical broadheads opposed to fixed blades will probably never end, but there are some factors worth noting about each. 

Mechanicals:

Pros) 

• Can be more accurate 

• Large cutting diameter

• Easy to store

• Can produce better blood trails

Cons) 

• Not as durable (Blade may break)

• Chance to malfunction or not open (More often with lower quality heads)

• Requires more kinetic energy for good penetration

Fixed blades:

Pros) 

• More durable

• Better penetration

• Cut on contact

• Most are easy to clean and resharpen for reuse

Cons) 

• Smaller cutting diameter

• Can be less accurate

• Harder to store without dulling blades

It is important to note that the success of every broadhead despite its type is relative to the shot made. A field point will kill a deer if the shot is placed perfectly.

This year I am using the Rage Mechanicals.